The History and Controversy of Dave Meltzer's 5 Star Ratings

Wrestling
Année2024

Since 1982, Dave Meltzer has given 258 matches a rating of 5 stars or better, and it often tends to cause a LOT of controversy. Why, now more than ever, does this one man's opinion generate such frenzied debate in the IWC? Let's look at the history of those stars and try to find out. Follow Kim Justice's Wrestling Road on Patreon for more documentaries: http://www.patreon.com/kimblejustice My Twitter: http://www.twitter.com/kimxxxjustice My Other Channel: http://www.youtube.com/kimblejustice A whole load of YouTube shoutouts (follow ALL of these channels, you should): Andos - @andos638 BDWJForever - @bdwjforever6980 Four Pillars of Hell - @fourpillarsofhell3331 Grappleholics - @grappleholics IQWrestler - @IQWrestler Joseph Montecillo - @JosephMontecilloYT ThunderFilez - @ThunderFilez Wrestle Me - @WrestleMe Wrestling Bios - @WrestlingBios Wrestling Colin - @WrestlingColin Other cool places: http://www.cagematch.net http://segundacaida.blogspot.com http://www.thecubsfan.com/cmll http://forums.prowrestlingonly.com 0:00 Intro 1:30 How Did We Start Using Star Scales for Wrestling? 7:00 The Sort of Wrestling Big Dave Enjoys 10:33 Why WWE Doesn't Often Get 5 Stars 13:49 AEW and the REAL Kings of the 5 Star Rating 17:00 Alternatives to Going on and on about Meltzer #kimjustice #wrestling #wrestlingcommunity #wrestlinghistory

Bande-annonce

Vous aimerez aussi

Wrestling★ 0

5 Times WWE Went TOO FAR

Wrestling★ 0

5 MOST STUPID Romance Storylines In WWE History

Wrestling★ 0

5 Best Pranks In WWE History

Wrestling★ 0

Story of The Intense Bidding War For Scott Steiner

Wrestling★ 0

When Evander Holyfield Confronted His Biggest Opponent

Wrestling★ 0

Black Panther vs Black Thunder: Super-Welterweight showdown | Matchroom Boxing

Wrestling★ 0

The ENTIRE History of IN YOUR HOUSE!

Wrestling★ 0

BLOOD and BONE BAREKNUCKLE | Jarome Hatch vs Cody East | BKB 42 Nashville

Wrestling★ 7.9

Luta Gel

Wrestling★ 0

Rough N' Rowdy Supports Sex Workers

Wrestling★ 7.0

That was painful

Wrestling★ 0

SGW Showdown: Slim Pally Kissed Martin Porno & Humiliated Morbious | Watch Full Match!

Wrestling★ 7.5

Taboo Mud Wrestling

Wrestling★ 7.6

Je Veux

Wrestling★ 7.7

Heather Monroe, Kiah Dream & Leila Grey

Wrestling★ 0

🔥WWE 2K25 - John Cena vs Nicky James : WWE2K Dec 19, 2025

Wrestling★ 0

Yuri Boyka vs Ong Bak | Taekwondo vs Muay Thai

Wrestling★ 0

Young But Deadly! Kids Show Off EPIC Kung Fu Power 💪

Wrestling★ 0

The Scorpion King Opening - BOO!

Wrestling★ 7.6

FULL MATCH: Team Roman Reigns vs. Team Seth Rollins | Elimination Tag Team Match: Raw, Nov. 2, 2015

Wrestling★ 0

GTA 6 IS FINALLY HERE? NETFLIX Extended Look Reaction! 4K

Wrestling★ 0

Winning The Belt! Boxing Mindset.

Wrestling★ 7.2

Jackie Chan & John Cena In Hollywood Full Action English Movie SPECIAL SOLDIERS - Free English Movie

Wrestling★ 7.8

Grey Hulk (2027) - John Cena, Margot Robbie, Mark Ruffalo | Concept Trailer

Commentaires

1 commentaires

King KayJan 23, 2026